Super Efficient Fans in India – a result of SEEP (Super Efficient Equipment Programme)

BEE launched its standards and labeling program in 2006 and since then many electrical appliances are being rated on their efficiency on a scale of 1-5. Most appliances are labeled and sold as BEE star rated appliances. Even after all these years, the level of efficiency of appliances in India has not reached the level of efficiency prevalent in most efficient appliances globally. A study by Prayas group of Pune suggests that if a rapid market transformation is done to only four appliances: room air conditioners, refrigerators, television sets, and ceiling fans: India has potential to save 60 million units of electricity (source). This translates to avoiding a peak capacity addition of 20,000 MW. In view of this BEE has launched a new program to support manufacturing of Super Efficient Appliances and the program has started with Fans.

Table of Contents

  • What are super efficient fans?
  • Comparing Numbers for various kinds of fans
  • What does Super Efficient Fan technology include?
  • Source of Information
  • Some Super Efficient Fans in India
  • Discussion Forum

What are super efficient fans?

A regular ceiling fan that does not include any efficient technology consumes 75-80 Watts of power. Since BEE introduced star rating for ceiling fans, we have started getting fans that are efficient to the point that they consume only 45-50 Watts of power. However some people had complaints with BEE 5 star rated fans about their air delivery being less (and some more, which we discussed in our previous post: BEE 5 Star rated ceiling fans: myths and realities). The regular fans have air delivery of about 250 cumm and BEE 5 star rated fans have air delivery of 210-225 cumm. Looking at all this BEE has proposed a Super Efficient Fan program where fans manufactured will consume only 30-35 Watts of power and would deliver about 230 cumm of air. In the previous post mentioned above, we have already written about our test results of a ceiling fan that delivers about 225 cumm of air and we hardly felt much difference as compared to regular fans. And thus we believe that 230 cumm is a good value.

Comparing Numbers for various kinds of fans

Looking at the high costs for buying a super efficient fan, most people would be interested in comparing numbers before making a buying decision. Below table compares all kinds of fans.

Regular Fan

BEE 5 star Rated Fan

Super Efficient Fan

Wattage

75

50

35

Yearly Units Consumption (assuming 8 hrs usage everyday)

219

146

102

Yearly Electricity Cost (at Rs 5 per unit)

Rs 1095

Rs 730

Rs 511

Cost of Buying

Rs 1200

Rs 1600

Rs 3000

Based on above numbers a BEE 5 star rated fan pays back for additional cost as compared to regular fan within one year.

A Super efficient fan will pay back for itself in about three and half years as compared to a regular fan.

These numbers can vary depending on your use and cost of electricity, which you can validate, using our calculator: Online Electricity Bill Calculator – For all states in India. If your using cost is more than 5 then the payback can be faster. If it is less then it will be slower.

What does Super Efficient Fan technology include?

There are 3 things that are done to improve the efficiency of fans in super efficient fans:

  1. Performance is improved by improving the induction motor.
  2. Use of BLDC (or Brushless DC technology). To know more about brushless DC technology check: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brushless_DC_electric_motor
  3. Improving the design of the blades.

The above implementations involve replacing some electrical components with electronic components thus allowing for a smoother control of the fans.

As per BEE specifications, these changes should allow super efficient fans to give:

  1. Higher air flow at full speed
  2. Low noise through the use of better quality blades;
  3. In order to be more suitable for Indian conditions:
    1. a.None or very low degradation in performance at lower voltages;
    2. b.Reliable even under high ambient temperature;
  4. Lowest power consumption reasonably possible.

The one downside of a super efficient fan is that the power factor of such fans is 0.9 as compared to 0.95 of regular fans with induction motors. It may impact commercial connections with demand charges in their tariff plan.

Source of Information

Author: sumitsharma

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *